Can You Make Popcorn In A Toaster Oven?

Exploring the delightful world of making popcorn beyond the traditional stovetop and microwave methods, this guide delves into the innovative use of a toaster oven for popping corn. A toaster oven, typically seen as a convenient appliance for reheating pizza or baking small batches of cookies, unveils its versatility and capability to create this beloved snack. Through a series of culinary experiments, I’ve discovered that not only can a toaster oven serve various cooking tasks, but it can also transform the simple act of making popcorn into a creative and enjoyable process.

This guide covers everything from the basic steps to safety tips, benefits, and even adding flavorings, offering a comprehensive look at how to elevate your popcorn game with a toaster oven.

How to Make Popcorn from Scratch in a Toaster Oven?

Making popcorn from scratch in a toaster oven is not only fun but gives you control over the oils, seasonings, and add-ins, making it a healthier option. Sure, the method makes a difference compared to cutting open a pre-made bag. Start by adding plain kernels, about ½ cup, into a container suitable for cooking with a tablespoon of oil to ensure each kernel becomes tender and popped when finished.

The great options for adding your own touch include Olive oil and sea salt, Herbs and parmesan cheese, Spicy seasonings like chili powder, cayenne pepper, and cumin, Cinnamon and brown sugar for a sweet touch, Nuts, dried fruit, or chocolate chips for texture, Toasted coconut or dried tropical fruit for an exotic taste, Lemon zest and basil for freshness, or even Bacon bits with bacon grease for a savory kick.

Mini marshmallows, pecans, and chocolate chunks can turn it into a dessert. With unlimited flavors to love, go for it! Most toppings should be added immediately after removing from the oven, which works best, with the exception of ingredients that need to melt.

  • Tips & Tricks

To cook the best batch of popcorn, here are a few tips and tricks. For tender and fluffy kernels, Shake the container at regular intervals to agitate the kernels, resulting in fewer unpopped ones. Add a bit of oil, about two tablespoons, to the unpopped kernels before placing them in the oven to help retain moisture. Do not try to use an oven tray; it’s suggested to use a bowl with a foil method to avoid a huge mess.

A reminder: NOT to use the bag from microwave popcorn in the toaster oven due to fire hazard. Sprinkle some salt or seasoning once finished for that fluffy texture. The foil top works much better than using the toaster oven cage, minimizing mess and improving the texture of the finished product.

Related Article: Boiled Popcorn: What Is It and How Can You Make It?

Toaster ovens are so versatile that you can even pop popcorn in them!

In my journey through culinary experiments, I’ve discovered that a toaster oven is not just a small, countertop appliance designed for reheating pizza or baking cookies. Beyond its capability to heat up a variety of food items, from pizzas to baked goods, certain models are surprisingly adept at making popcorn. This revelation might not align with the traditional stovetop method many of us are accustomed to, but the essence of cooking is exploration and innovation. If you’re looking for information on whether these appliances truly work for popping corn and if they’re worth purchasing, let me share my personal experience.

Using a toaster oven for popping corn requires a bit of creativity, given it wasn’t designed with this task in mind. Yet, the versatility and the direct heat it provides can create a delightful snack. It’s a testament to the appliance’s utility, challenging the conventional use and showcasing its ability to tackle a wide variety of cooking tasks. Whether you’re considering adding a toaster oven to your kitchen arsenal or you already own one, trying out popcorn in it might just elevate your snacking game.

Using a toaster oven to pop popcorn

When you’re craving popcorn but don’t want to use the stovetop and can’t rely on a microwave, the toaster oven emerges as a great solution for small batches of this quintessential snack. Unlike a single bag of microwave popcorn, the toaster oven provides a unique approach to reheating leftovers or keeping snacks warm while your main course gets ready. Its smaller size compared to standard ovens makes cleanup easier, turning it into a versatile kitchen ally beyond just preparing meals.

Related Article: How to Make Popcorn with Soybean Oil?

Why not use a toaster oven for popcorn

While deciding to do it, making popcorn in a toaster oven is not for everyone. The methods of cooking popcorn vary, but if you need to use a toaster oven, you’ll need a cookie sheet you don’t have to buy from the grocery store for $5. To stay in place, spread ½ cup of popcorn kernels in an even layer and sprinkle with salt to help them pop. With inside set to high heat, they’ll start popping; keep an eye on them as they might be done before five minutes. Once finished, they may fly around and are susceptible to burning.

Is Using a Toaster Oven Healthier Than the Microwave?

Using a toaster oven is not healthier than a microwave, and here’s why. Surprised? Despite the small amount of radiation associated with microwave cooking, it’s a faster cooking method that retains more nutrients, making the food that comes out of a microwave often healthier than that from a toaster oven. In terms of popcorn, the cooking time is relatively quick either way, making neither option inherently unhealthy. The real health factor when discussing popcorn comes into play with the types of fat, seasonings, and mix-ins used in making it.

Can You Make Popcorn In A Toaster Oven?

How to Stay Safe When Cooking Popcorn in a Toaster Oven?

Cooking popcorn in a toaster oven is both convenient and simple, but it’s crucial to stay safe while using it. First, make sure your toaster oven isn’t located directly beneath any kitchen cabinets to reduce the fire risk. Keeping the appliance clean and removing food debris after each use minimizes the chance of a fire. When making popcorn, avoid using oil that should be cooked on the stove for its rich taste that boosts the flavor; never use it in your toaster oven to save your popcorn after it’s cooked.

Always use a toaster oven-safe dish, whether it’s silicone, glass, ceramic, or copper; you must use one, otherwise, the dish will break and ruin your popcorn. And, don’t forget to use oven-proof gloves as the dish becomes very hot when transferring.

Related Article: How to Add Cheese Flavor to Your Popcorn?

What Are the Benefits of Making Popcorn in a Toaster Oven?

Discussed the easy way to make popcorn in a toaster oven, one of the biggest benefits is that it’s a healthy option. Since it can’t be cooked with oil, it becomes a healthier option than stove top or cooked popcorn and healthier than microwave popcorn, avoiding risks associated with microwave popcorn like popcorn lung. No burned popcorn smell or lingering smell of burned popcorn that you get with microwave popcorn. You can remove it as soon as popping stops.

Cooked at the same time with other dishes due to the size of the toaster oven, you can cook a batch of popcorn while cooking other foods. Fewer unpopped kernels, since unpopped kernels taste bad and get stuck in your teeth, is a big benefit of cooking in a toaster oven, as you get fewer unpopped kernels compared to when you cook popcorn on the stove.

What is the Best Way to Cook Popcorn?

The best way to cook popcorn is undoubtedly the stovetop traditional technique. Using a heavy-bottomed saucepan with a lid, coat the bottom with a few tablespoons of cooking oil. Start with a few test corn kernels and heat at medium-high. Once these test kernels pop, it indicates the oil is hot enough to add the remaining kernels. Pour in about a cup of popcorn kernels into the pan, and gently shake the pot occasionally to ensure the corn kernels continue to pop evenly.

When the popping subsides, remove the pan from the heat and pour the popcorn into a serving bowl to enjoy. This stovetop cooking technique helps achieve a perfectly puffed morsel of popcorn, a method worth discussing for its superior results.

Related Article: How to make popcorn with coconut oil?

Should I Shake or Stir Popcorn?

To agitate the kernels effectively, both shaking and stirring are crucial methods as the batch heats. Utilizing circulating heat, whether it’s air or hot oil, ensures each kernel heats efficiently. In a toaster oven, where the batch often sits in a pile in a bowl, shaking ensures that kernels least exposed to the heat get a chance to burst. A stovetop popper with a cool-touch stir handle can similarly keep the kernels agitated for even popping.


The exploration of using a toaster oven to pop popcorn unveils a realm of culinary creativity and innovation, presenting a delightful alternative to conventional methods. This guide has walked you through the basics, from the initial steps to essential safety tips, and even how to enhance your popcorn with a variety of flavorings. It has debunked myths, highlighted the health benefits, and showcased the toaster oven as an unexpectedly perfect appliance for making popcorn. Whether you’re a popcorn aficionado or a curious cook, the journey into toaster oven popcorn offers a fresh perspective on enjoying this timeless snack, making it a worthwhile adventure for your taste buds and cooking repertoire.


Is a Toaster Oven a Good Way to Cook Popcorn?

Yes, a toaster oven is a good way to cook popcorn, allowing you to make a snack that smells and tastes great. It's the perfect way to treat yourself after a hard day of work.

Can You Put Flavorings on Toaster Oven Popcorn?

Yes, flavoring toaster oven popcorn is not only possible but encouraged! Add your flavorings after it's cooked for a quick and easy way to make your snack times more exciting. Whether you're trying out different flavorings for your favorite movie night with friends or just making rounds of lots of small batches for a variety, topped with your preferred flavorings to keep everyone happy. Some great flavorings to try include Parmesan cheese, Caramel, Ranch, Garlic and herb, Peanut butter, White chocolate, Pecan, and Cheddar cheese.

Can I Use the Oven Instead of the Microwave for Popcorn?

Possible? Absolutely, and it works much better with a toaster oven than a conventional one, but a regular oven can still work if you don’t have anything else handy. Take out the bag to lessen the fire risk. The method is essentially the same: make sure to heat from the bottom within a given range, and shake the container regularly to keep the kernels moving and avoid burning. Making popcorn in a toaster oven should be your go-to method, as it provides tender, fluffy kernels of your favorite snack in a pretty easy, decidedly uncomplicated way. The reason for not having a microwave doesn’t need to stop you from enjoying a delicious bowl of salty, buttery popcorn.

Leave a Comment